Comments (14)Add a Comment
Alex is traumatized and bullied during a high school play. Terry Fallis demonstrates how devastating bullying can be to an individual's life. After his mother dies, Alex discovers that he has an identical twin . When Alex finally meets his twin, that is when the fun begins! Terry Fallis has an identical twin in real life, and he must have enjoyed writing this novel. :)
One Brother Shy is the SDG Reads title selection for 2018. It is a quirky book. The storylines did not come together for me. I did love all of the references to Ottawa; however, Fallis made one mistake referring to Alex's apartment in the Glebe rather than in Sandy Hill.
I’d say I read this book in one sitting, but several times I had to put it down because I could no longer see the text through my tears (and there’s also that pesky need to sleep.) I enjoy Fallis' writing, especially the various Canadianisms throughout. (An outrage! one of the Goodreads reviewers gave the book a low score and said it was too Canadian, “not that there’s anything wrong with being Canadian.”) For me, it is always a relief to read a novel with a therapist character that does not make me wince or feel ill. Globe and Mail: “Terry Fallis writes just about the tidiest romantic comedic novels you can find on Earth, let alone in Canada.”
This is a light read for anyone who doesn't want to think too much but just go with the flow of the story. Alex has issues with socializing, the cause of which we are told is something to do with Gabriel. He is a programmer living with his dying mother, and then the inevitable happens. His mother has left him a photograph that starts him on a quest to discover his roots. He is successful, and during the search he manages to deal with his psychological troubles and come out the other side as a healthier person. There is a spot in the book where Fallis does a bit of soapboxing on social licence and the need for stakeholder input. It was not really necessary to the story but I read it and forgave him. The direction of the whole plot is pretty predictable from about halfway through, but still I wanted to finish reading to get to the feel-good ending. It is always nice when things turn out the way you expect them to.
Nice to hear all the references to Ottawa and historical events of Canadian interest. But it is a very one dimensional story at about the grade 6 level.
3.5 stars. An engaging, light-hearted read with a very likeable protagonist that touches on some pretty serious subjects. This title was a nice change from some of the ultra-dark books that I've been reading lately.
This is a likable quick read. The “Gabriel” incident caused the main character to cocoon himself from life for years. Now with strong family support, he was finally ready broke through and be his true self again. The story has humour, mystery and heart warming.
The Whistler Public Library and Armchair Books book club read "One Brother Shy" in September 2017. Terry Fallis will be in Whistler next weekend for the Whistler Writers Festival, so we were all keen to read his latest novel. No one had trouble finishing this book, although it didn't have much of an impact on most of our readers. We agreed that it was an easy, light read, but it wasn't wall-to-wall laughs like some of Fallis' early work.
We particularly enjoyed discussing:
- The subjectivity of humour. We don't often read funny books in this club, partially because humour is SO subjective, and some of our members avoid reading humour altogether, because it is so often at someone's expense. (We shared our favourite funny books as well, many of which were memoirs.)
- Terry Fallis' body of work. Those of us who have read more than one of his books agreed that One Brother Shy isn't his best work, but it's still highly readable, light, and easy. The Best Laid Plans (his first novel) was the unanimous favourite.
- Bullying in the digital age. One of the major plot points in this novel revolves around a highly traumatic case of cyber-bullying. We discussed how bullying has changed over the years, and how damaging it can be now that it's so easy to disseminate humiliating photos and videos.
We recognize Fallis' style again, though the theme has changed from politics to long lost twin brothers and hockey, so Canadian thread is conserved though the novel largely takes place outside of Canada. We can detect that this is a new area of exploration for Fallis and the story is not as tight and punchy as in Well Laid Plans. The plot goes a bit beyond the believable, but I forgive him that because after all, this is fiction, and what Canadian doesn't enjoy a bit of hockey!
Some clever lines but the writing is slap-dash and plot is shallow. There were no surprises and everything was so predictable. Over 400 pages for what could be reduced to a short story.
I loved this book. I found the story very poignant, it pulled at my heartstrings without going overboard into sentimentality. I loved the characters, the situation, and the resolution. I would recommend this book to anyone who enjoys a good read.
This was perhaps not the perfect book for me but I still want to recommend it to anyone who is looking for a charming, entertaining, easy read for the summer. If you normally read Terry Fallis, you will enjoy this book.
Just finished reading "One Brother Shy". Besides being very engaging, well-written, and witty - it was an exciting rollercoaster of a ride! While it did leave me feeling very good, I thought it was definitely more than just a 'feel-good' book.